• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About Strata-gee
  • Contact Us
  • Free Newsletter
  • Sponsor Strata-gee
  • Privacy Policy
  • Latest Posts
  • Strategy
  • Technology
  • Products
  • People
  • Statistics
  • Financial
  • Legal
  • Economic
  • Events

Strata-gee.com

Strategy in TECH...

What Savant Can Do
You are here: Home / Law / Sonos v. HEOS – War is Over, Peace Has Come

Sonos v. HEOS – War is Over, Peace Has Come

May 21, 2018 by Ted Leave a Comment

hippie family w/peace signOn Friday last week, we learned that Sonos and D&M Holdings have settled their litigation, first begun in October 2014. Although the terms of the settlement are confidential, all actions taken by each party are now moot.

It is likely that the parties now enjoy some form of licensing arrangement that put all adversarial issues behind them.

See more on what we know about the end of the Sonos and D&M patent war…



We first heard from Sound United, the new home of all things D&M Holdings-related, including the HEOS wireless multi-room music system, the subject of a patent infringement lawsuit brought by Sonos back in late 2014. On Friday, the same day a document notifying the judge of a joint stipulation of settlement was filed with the court, Sound United put out a brief two-paragraph statement saying all litigation between that parties has been settled.

AudioControl Single Zone Amps

The Sound United statement says that the terms of the agreement are confidential. No other information is given. However, in a quote from Sound United CEO Kevin Duffy, he says, “Our direction with HEOS is unchanged, and we’ll continue providing amazing sounding solutions globally while furthering our vision of delivering joy to the world through sound.”

We Can Only Conclude a Royalty Fee for HEOS is the Result

While not explicitly articulated, one only conclude from this statement that D&M must now pay royalties on each HEOS product shipped that contains basic technologies patented by Sonos that a jury had determined D&M had violated with their HEOS line. This could mean that HEOS prices will rise, or perhaps the company will seek to “hide” the royalty in newly designed models which will delete certain features to reduce the cost such that the addition of a royalty fee will be invisible to the consumer.War is Over graphic for Sound United

Later, Sonos posted a statement on their blog which also announced the agreement and also included the language, “The terms are confidential.” The blog  post, penned by Mark Triplett, VP, Intellectual Property, did go on to say, however, that when Sonos first sued D&M, the action  was taken with the “firm belief in genuine innovation and mutual respect for intellectual property as a basis for healthy competition.”

Sonos: ‘Denon’s Intentional and Blatant Copying’



The statement went on to add: “At the time, it was our view that Denon was simply copying the work we spent years creating for its own HEOS product line. The litigation against Denon brought validation to our beliefs – most notably in a December 2017 jury trial. In that trial the jury affirmed the validity of three of our foundational patents. The jury also, when presented with overwhelming evidence of Denon’s intentional and blatant copying, found that Denon willfully infringed our patents.”

Register for CEDIA Expo

D&M, the Sonos statement says, has approached Sonos “with what we believed was a fair and favorable resolution.”

Jury Found in Favor of Sonos

So it doesn’t take much reading between the lines to guess just what this outcome was. It is pretty clear that this language suggests that HEOS will pay a royalty fee or license fee to Sonos.

As we reported in December when the first of what was expected to be three trials – a bellwether trial no less – was over, Sonos won their case on all counts, without reservation by the jury. It was an ominous sign for D&M – especially when you consider the judge set this first trial as a bellwether trial, or a trial designed to help clarify issues that would be decided in additional trials – using the results from the first trial as guidance for how future juries should view the remaining issues.War is Over - Sonos

D&M Ordered to Pay Millions to Sonos



Although D&M would ultimately file a countersuit, alleging that Sonos had violated D&M patents…this appeared to be more of a retaliatory action, rather than a serious threat in the eyes of Sonos’s attorneys. The jury in the first trial had awarded Sonos just under $2,000,000. In post-trial motions, Sonos appeared to be poised to get those awards increased, perhaps dramatically.

Now, this is all water under the bridge and the parties move forward. Sonos, however, is apparently feeling vindicated…perhaps ready to pounce on the next perceived violator of its foundational patents.

We reached out to both sides for additional comment, D&M did not respond, and Sonos chose to let their written statement be the last word on this matter.

FULL SOUND UNITED STATEMENT

VISTA, Calif., May 18, 2018  — Sound United, parent company to leading audio brands Denon, Marantz, Polk Audio, Definitive Technology, HEOS, Boston Acoustics and Classé Audio, announced today that it has reached a settlement with Sonos, resolving all patent infringement litigation between the two companies including the upcoming case filed against Sonos by Denon. Terms of the agreement are confidential.

“Today’s agreement demonstrates our belief in moving the industry forward and removing barriers for both parties to deliver products that delight customers,” said Kevin Duffy, CEO of Sound United. “Our direction with HEOS is unchanged, and we’ll continue providing amazing-sounding solutions globally while furthering our vision of delivering joy to the world through sound.”

See more about Sound United at: www.soundunited.com.

FULL SONOS STATEMENT

Today, Sonos and Sound United signed an agreement to resolve all patent infringement litigation between the two companies. The terms are confidential.

When we embarked on this effort back in October 2014, we did so out of a firm belief in genuine innovation and mutual respect for intellectual property as a basis for healthy competition. At the time, it was our view that Denon was simply copying the work we spent years creating for its own HEOS product line.

The litigation against Denon brought validation to our beliefs – most notably in a December 2017 jury trial.  In that trial, the jury affirmed the validity of three of our foundational patents.  The jury also, when presented with overwhelming evidence of Denon’s intentional and blatant copying, found that Denon willfully infringed our patents.

Subsequently, D&M approached us with what we believed was a fair and favorable resolution. We’re excited to close this chapter successfully with this settlement.  This litigation affirmed our belief that our patent portfolio is foundational, and enables Sonos to continue to invent, inspire the industry, and delight our customers.

Mark Triplett
VP, Intellectual Property

Learn more about Sonos at: www.sonos.com.


Share this post:

  • Tweet
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • More
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Sonos logo

Judge Finds Against D&M; Affirms Sonos Patents

BREAKING NEWS Delaware District Judge Richard G. Andrews has delivered a decision that is sure to be a blow against D&M Holdings' defense in its now long-running patent infringement dispute with Sonos, originally filed in October 2014. Judge Andrews has denied a motion by D&M to invalidate four key Sonos…

March 16, 2017

In "Law"

Exhibit F Sonos Motion

Sonos to Seek Injunction to Stop HEOS Sales of ‘Infringing Technology’

BREAKING NEWS Case May Have Major Impact on Wireless Speaker Business As we recently reported, a federal jury gave Sonos a sweeping victory in the first "bellwether trial" in Sonos Inc. v. D&M Holdings Inc. et al, siding with Sonos on all counts and awarding them nearly $2 million in…

December 20, 2017

In "Brands"

Sonos logo

Verdict: ‘Denon Directly Infringed’ on Sonos Patents

BREAKING NEWS Jury Finds for Sonos on All Counts; Denon Claims of Invalidity Vanquished Last Friday, after a full week of testimony, evidence, deposition playbacks, and attorney posturing, members of the jury listened closely as Judge William C. Bryson delivered instructions designed to clarify their deliberative process and their duty…

December 18, 2017

In "Brands"

Filed Under: Law Tagged With: D&M, D&M Holdings, Denon, HEOS, HEOS by Denon, Sonos

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Search

Sign-Up for Our FREE Newsletter

loader

Latest Posts

Sonos Board Decides to Upgrade Interim CEO Tom Conrad to Official CEO

Sonos, Inc. [Nasdaq: SONO] announced today that its Board of Directors has … [Read More...] about Sonos Board Decides to Upgrade Interim CEO Tom Conrad to Official CEO

  • New Housing Starts in June Rebound 4.6% From May, But Remain Below 2024
  • Premium Audio Company and Pioneer Corp Formally End Partnership
  • A Tough Task, A Turbulent Time; Yet Manley Labs Owner Overcomes All to Achieve the American Dream

Categories

Sponsors

Crestron Register for Expo
AudioControl Single Zone Amps
Sonance James Small Aperture
Savant

Tag Cloud

acquisition Amazon Apple AudioControl B&W Bowers & Wilkins CEDIA CEDIA Expo CES Control4 Core Brands COVID-19 Crestron D&M Holdings Denon Emerald Expositions Foxconn Gibson Brands Gibson Guitar Google headphones Henry Juszkiewicz Hon Hai Precision Industry Co. housing starts Integra Joe Kiani LG Masimo Nortek OLED Onkyo Panasonic patent infringement Pioneer Samsung Savant Sharp smart home SnapAV Snap One Sonos Sony Sound United SpeakerCraft Toshiba

Footer

Got News?

HEY PR & Marketing Pros: Have NEWS for Strata-gee readers?

Send it to: HotNews@strata-gee.com

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Sponsor Strata-gee

Strata-gee Ads

Archives

Translate

Ted Green Bio

A former dealer, manufacturer, distributor & more. Focusing on business strategy, my goal is to help you make better decisions for greater success.

Follow Ted Green

  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram

Copyright © 2025 Strata-gee.com · The Stratecon Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved · Log in

%d