• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About Strata-gee
  • Contact Us
  • Free Newsletter
  • Sponsor Strata-gee
  • Privacy Policy
  • Latest Posts
  • Strategy
  • Technology
  • Products
  • People
  • Statistics
  • Financial
  • Legal
  • Economic
  • Events

Strata-gee.com

Strategy in TECH...

Sonance James Small Aperture Series
You are here: Home / Law / In a Shocking Reversal, Judge Grants Dish Motion; Throws Out Jury Verdict

In a Shocking Reversal, Judge Grants Dish Motion; Throws Out Jury Verdict

March 21, 2023 by Ted Leave a Comment

BREAKING NEWS

On Tuesday, less than two weeks after the conclusion of a trial in the case of ClearPlay, Inc. vs. Dish Network where a jury found in favor of ClearPlay and ordered Dish Network to pay $470 million for patent infringement – Judge David Nuffer announced a new ruling that throws out the jury verdict and award. This dramatic turnabout was announced during a court status hearing on Tuesday in which the parties participated via Zoom.

See more on this dramatic reversal

Today, I received a communication from the Dish Network communications team letting me know that there had been a major turn of events in the case that I reported on just last week. In that case, a jury had handed a win to ClearPlay and a significant judgment against Dish Network.

Today, the court held a status hearing in which the judge handed down his ruling on an outstanding motion. That motion was filed by Dish Network and titled: Defendants’ Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law Under Rule 50(A).

Sonance James Small Aperture

Defendant Dish’s Motion Said ClearPlay’s Pleadings were Deficient in Showing Infringement

The purpose of this motion by Dish was to argue that ClearPlay’s pleadings were deficient by failing to offer enough evidence to show infringement, and as such the Court should find in favor of the defendant “as a matter of law” – based very specifically on the language of the law. This motion had been filed by Dish on March 3rd, about a week before the trial began, and had not been ruled upon by the time of the trial…which ultimately concluded on March 10, 2023.

Here is the statement I received from a Dish spokesperson late in the day Tuesday, March 21st:

Earlier today, the judge in the ClearPlay v. DISH Network case ruled orally that he will grant DISH’s Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law. The ruling (sometimes called a directed verdict) means that the Court determined that ClearPlay failed to put on sufficient evidence to support the conclusion that DISH infringed the asserted patent claims. As a result, the jury’s March 10, 2023 verdict and damages award are moot. DISH has stood firm in its belief that it did not infringe ClearPlay’s patents, and is gratified by the Court’s ruling.

Dish Network spokesperson

A Complete Reversal for ClearPlay

As the Dish statement notes, the jury verdict and damages are moot with this ruling, a complete reversal from where ClearPlay was at the end of the trial. All that remains is for a mutually agreed upon version of the formal order to be drafted and signed by the judge, an action which should take place within the next few weeks.

clearplay website
ClearPlay website

On the court’s electronic filing system, the docket contains the following text which briefly explains the judge’s thinking:

Savant

Because the methods of the Accused Products do not practice the Asserted Claims of the 970 and 799 Patents and do not directly infringe the Asserted Claims, ClearPlays claims for literal infringement, infringement under the doctrine of equivalents, induced infringement, and willful infringement fail as a matter of law. For these reasons, Dishs 862 Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law will be GRANTED.

Judge David Nuffer, United States District Court, District of Utah, Central Division

I Have Reached Out to ClearPlay for a Reaction

I have reached out to ClearPlay for their reaction to this turn of events and if I hear back from them, I will update this story.

Learn more about Dish Network by visiting dish.com.

See more on ClearPlay at clearplay.com.

Share this post:

  • Tweet
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • More
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Filed Under: Financial, Law, News Tagged With: ClearPlay, Dish Network, EchoStar, patent infringement

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Search

Sign-Up for Our FREE Newsletter

loader

Latest Posts

T-Day+1: Tariffs…And So It Begins…

**NEW Update 7/11/25** - See Updated Tariff Programs from Around the … [Read More...] about T-Day+1: Tariffs…And So It Begins…

Latest Financial Results for Samsung and LG Show Impact of Trade Troubles

Two major South Korean tech behemoths, Samsung Electronics and LG Electronics, … [Read More...] about Latest Financial Results for Samsung and LG Show Impact of Trade Troubles

  • T-Day+1: Tariffs…And So It Begins…
  • Tariffs: New Business Survey Shows Companies are Already Feeling the Pain
  • Harman Luxury Audio Group Names Progressive Custom Integration as Rep for 7 Territories
  • Happy Independence Day!

Categories

Sponsors

Crestron Register for Expo
AudioControl Single Zone Amps
Sonance James Small Aperture
Savant
Oasys Residential Technology Group

Tag Cloud

acquisition Amazon Apple AudioControl B&W Bowers & Wilkins CEDIA CEDIA Expo CES Control4 Core Brands COVID-19 Crestron D&M Holdings Denon Emerald Expositions Foxconn Gibson Brands Gibson Guitar Google headphones Henry Juszkiewicz Hon Hai Precision Industry Co. housing starts Integra Joe Kiani LG Masimo Nortek OLED Onkyo Panasonic patent infringement Pioneer Samsung Savant Sharp smart home SnapAV Snap One Sonos Sony Sound United SpeakerCraft Toshiba

Footer

Got News?

HEY PR & Marketing Pros: Have NEWS for Strata-gee readers?

Send it to: HotNews@strata-gee.com

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Sponsor Strata-gee

Strata-gee Ads

Archives

Translate

Ted Green Bio

A former dealer, manufacturer, distributor & more. Focusing on business strategy, my goal is to help you make better decisions for greater success.

Follow Ted Green

  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram

Copyright © 2025 Strata-gee.com · The Stratecon Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved · Log in

%d