• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About Strata-gee
  • Contact Us
  • Free Newsletter
  • Sponsor Strata-gee
  • Privacy Policy
  • Latest Posts
  • Strategy
  • Technology
  • Products
  • People
  • Statistics
  • Financial
  • Legal
  • Economic Data
  • Shows & Events

Strata-gee.com

Strategy in TECH...

AudioControl Single Zone Amps
You are here: Home / Law / Beats Wins; Monster Loses Lawsuit Over Alleged Dirty Dealing

Beats Wins; Monster Loses Lawsuit Over Alleged Dirty Dealing

September 1, 2016 by Ted Leave a Comment

Trial is Now on Defendants’ Efforts to Recover Lawyers Fees

Photo of Dr. Dre and Jimmy Iovine
Dr. Dre & Jimmy Iovine of Beats

The fat lady hasn’t sung yet, but it’s pretty much all over for Monster LLC and Noel Lee’s lawsuit against Beats Electronics LLC, Andre Young (a/k/a Dr. Dre), Jimmy Iovine, Paul D. Wachter (a Beats director), HTC America Holding, Inc and Does 1-25 (defendants to be named later). LA Superior Court Judge William F. Fahey has dismissed Monster’s lawsuit in its entirety, and has scheduled a trial that is now only on the claims by the defendants against Monster for attorneys fees and other costs.

See more on this stunning defeat for Monster…



We first told you about this suit which was filed with great fanfare on the eve of the January 2015 Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas, NV. In the lawsuit, Monster claimed, among other things, that Beats and HTC had conspired to create a “sham” transaction in order to invoke a “change of control” clause that would terminate a license agreement that Monster held with Beats. The reason for this ruse, Monster claimed, was to get Monster out of the way and maximize profits from the $3 billion purchase of Beats by Apple, Inc.

In the lawsuit, we learned that Noel Lee held a 5% stake in Beats as part of their deal. But Lee said he was duped into selling his remaining 1.25% stake for $5.5 million. Had he held on to that stake, it would have been worth $30 million in the sale of Beats to Apple.

Crestron Infra-Bass

Monster Did Not Win a Single Point

In a quick read of the judge’s decision, it doesn’t appear that Monster won a single point. Judge Fahey determined that in Monster’s contract with Beats, they had agreed to language that included the change of control clause. And, the Judge noted, “Plaintiff [Monster] did not obtain the right to approve the change of control.”

In fact, the judge noted that the language of the agreement did not even “require that any change of control had to be objectively reasonable.” Yes, that’s right, the judge is saying that the contract permitted an unreasonable change of control, should Beats want to go that route.

Photo from Monster Cable 2012 CEA Line Show

Judge Pointed Out Technical Errors



Although it probably didn’t affect the outcome of the judge’s decision, we note that he took the time to point out a few technical errors by Monster’s attorneys.

Savant

“Second, CRC 3.1110(f) requires that exhibits be tabbed. As the court noted during the August 10, 2016 hearing, this is especially important in a case such as this one where the parties have filed thousands of pages of exhibits. Plaintiffs counsel requested, and was granted, leave to file properly tabbed exhibits. However, plaintiffs only partially cured their violation of this rule…”

“Third, CRC3.1354c mandates that any party making written objections to evidence ‘must submit with the objections a proposed order.’ Here, Beats and Wachter did so and their objections have been ruled upon in an order dated August 29, 2016 [footnote omitted]. Plaintiffs failed to provide written orders in support of their objections, which are now overruled.”

Trial Will Be Held on Defendants’ Claims for Attorneys Fees and other Costs



In a footnote, the judge noted that “Plaintiffs’ cases are mostly not on point.” In other words, their legal citations were for cases that were not germane to the issues in this case.

The trial is scheduled to begin next week and its only purpose now is to determine whether Monster will have to reimburse Beats Electronics, LLC and other parties legal fees and other costs associated with this action.

The Associated Press attempted to get comments on the case from Apple and Monster’s attorney, but was unsuccessful.


Share this post:

  • Tweet
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • More
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Filed Under: Brands, Financial, Law, News, Pivot Point Tagged With: Andre Young, Beats, Beats Electronics, HTC, HTC America, Jimmy Iovine, Monster, Noel Lee, Paul Wachter

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Search

Sign-Up for Our FREE Newsletter

loader

Latest Posts

T-Day+1: Tariffs…And So It Begins…

**UPDATED 5/22/25** - See a Selection of Tariff Increases from Around the … [Read More...] about T-Day+1: Tariffs…And So It Begins…

In Its Boldest Move Yet, AVPro Global Acquires Control Solutions Maker RTI

We got a blockbuster announcement late this afternoon as AVPro Global announced … [Read More...] about In Its Boldest Move Yet, AVPro Global Acquires Control Solutions Maker RTI

  • T-Day+1: Tariffs…And So It Begins…
  • ‘Legendary’ Judge Alsup Featured in Strata-gee May Go ‘Inactive’ in 2025
  • Masimo Updates SEC on Its Progress Recovering From Recent Cyberattack
  • Harman Hits Voxx Int’l & Klipsch Group with Major 13-Count Lawsuit

Categories

Sponsors

Crestron Infra-Bass
AudioControl Single Zone Amps
Sonance James Small Aperture
Savant
Oasys Residential Technology Group

Tag Cloud

acquisition Amazon Apple AudioControl B&W Bowers & Wilkins CEDIA CEDIA Expo CES Control4 Core Brands COVID-19 Crestron D&M Holdings Denon Emerald Expositions Foxconn Gibson Brands Gibson Guitar Google Henry Juszkiewicz Hon Hai Precision Industry Co. housing starts Integra Joe Kiani LG Marantz Masimo Nortek OLED Onkyo Panasonic patent infringement Pioneer Samsung Savant Sharp smart home SnapAV Snap One Sonos Sony Sound United SpeakerCraft Toshiba

Footer

Got News?

HEY PR & Marketing Pros: Have NEWS for Strata-gee readers?

Send it to: HotNews@strata-gee.com

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Sponsor Strata-gee

Strata-gee Ads

Archives

Translate

Ted Green Bio

A former dealer, manufacturer, distributor & more. Focusing on business strategy, my goal is to help you make better decisions for greater success.

Follow Ted Green

  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram

Copyright © 2025 Strata-gee.com · The Stratecon Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved · Log in

%d