• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About Strata-gee
  • Contact Us
  • Free Newsletter
  • Sponsor Strata-gee
  • Privacy Policy
  • Latest Posts
  • Strategy
  • Technology
  • Products
  • People
  • Statistics
  • Financial
  • Legal
  • Economic Data
  • Shows & Events

Strata-gee.com

Strategy in TECH...

AudioControl Single Zone Amps
You are here: Home / Manufacturers / U.S. Dept. of Justice Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Apple & Five Publishers

U.S. Dept. of Justice Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Apple & Five Publishers

April 12, 2012 by Ted Leave a Comment

<April 11, 2012> The Department of Justice (DOJ) today filed an antitrust civil lawsuit against Apple, Inc. and five major book publishers, alleging that the parties had formed an illegal cabal for the purpose of artificially inflating the price of e-books. The publishers charged in the action were Hachette SA, HarperCollins, Macmillan, Penguin and Simon & Schuster.

According to the lawsuit, the result of the conspirators actions caused “e-book consumers to pay tens of millions of dollars more for e-books than they otherwise would have paid.” Later in the day it was revealed that three of the publishers – Hachette, Simon & Schuster, and HarperCollins – have agreed to a settlement with the government.

Apple iPadsThe $9.99 problem…
The action by the DOJ follows a several months-long investigation centered largely around the activities of the alleged conspirators back in 2010 during the time when Apple was planning to launch the iPad and was meeting with publishers regarding supplying their iBookstore.

Crestron Infra-Bass

Why would these companies allegedly come together on pricing issues? According to DOJ, publishers were concerned about what they called the $9.99 problem. This problem is a reference to the price that Amazon.com was using to set launches of new bestsellers. The $9.99 was way below the approximately $19.99 list price and many publishers felt that Amazon was trying to drive market share to both help their fledgling Kindle e-Book reader, and to create a monopoly of the e-Book market.

Discussing Amazon’s pricing…
The DOJ’s suit describes how the publisher’s CEOs, competitors in the marketplace, began meeting regularly every several months “in private dining rooms of upscale Manhattan restaurants” in order to “discuss confidential business and competitive matters, including Amazon’s e-book retailing practices.”

These meetings “provided the publisher defendants’ C.E.O.’s the opportunity to discuss how they collectively could solve ‘the $9.99 problem.'”

Steve Jobs’ “agency” solution…
The answer, the DOJ alleges, came from Apple’s famous former CEO, Steve Jobs who proposed to the publishers to transition away from the more typical wholesale model – where publishers sell the books in large quantities to Amazon at 50% of the retail price with Amazon free to set its own pricing – to an “agency” model – where the publishers set the retail price and pay Amazon a set commission of 30%. In the agency model, the reseller is prohibited from adjusting the selling price.

Sonance James Small Aperture

The suit actually quotes Steve Jobs: “We’ll go to [an] agency model, where you set the price, and we get our 30%, and yes, the customer pays a little more, but that’s what you want anyway.”

Apple was said to refer to the idea as an “aikido move.”

An ideal solution…Apple Headquarters
This seemed like an ideal solution with the added benefit of the publishers making more profit under the agency model. However, Apple also insisted on a “most favored nation” clause which prohibited publishers from allowing other retailers to sell e-books at a price lower than Apple.

After consummating their deal with Apple in 2010, the five publishers then re-negotiated their deal with Amazon, switching them to an agency style relationship. Amazon had no choice but to go along with the arrangement – given the collective power of these major publishers.

Result? Amazon’s share down, consumer prices up…
The result? Since 2010, Amazon has seen their e-book market share drop from 90% to 60% according to a report in the New York Times. Also, Barnes & Noble watched their market share grow to 25% of the business. Apple’s iBookstore is said to have a market share of between 10% to 15%.

And perhaps more importantly, retail prices on books have moved up from Amazon’s $9.99 to between $12.99 to $14.99. These price increases did not go unnoticed and there was much outcry when the agency model was first put into place.

Damaging evidence…
The government’s suit contains substantial amounts of damaging evidence including an email exchange from an unnamed publisher encouraging the participants to work together to get Amazon’s prices up.

“We’ve always known that unless other publishers follow us, there’s no chance of success in getting Amazon to change its pricing practices,” one email said.

“Without a critical mass behind us, Amazon won’t ‘negotiate,’ so we need to be more confident of how our fellow publishers will react,” the email added.

A trio of ‘settlers’ & prohibition…
The three publishers who have settled, Hachette, Simon & Schuster, and HarperCollins will now terminate their agreements with Apple and other e-book sellers and will be prohibited for two years from entering into new agreements that constrain retailers’ ability to offer discounts or other promotions to consumers to encourage the sale of the publishers’ e-books. Interesting, they are not prohibited from entering into agency agreements, only from agreements that prohibit retailers from reducing the price set by the publisher.

The settling publishers will also be prohibited for five years from again conspiring with or sharing competitively sensitive information with their competitors. They will also be subject to implementing a strong antitrust compliance program and must regularly report to the department on any communications they have with other publishers.

Also, over the next five years, the settling publishers are prohibited from having any type of most favored nation agreements that could undermine the effectiveness of the settlement agreement.

As for Apple, Macmillan, and Penguin…the fight goes on.

>>Want to see all the gory details?
The ALERT has obtained a copy of the DOJ lawsuit, click the link here to download> – ebooks04112012 (be patient, its a pretty large file and may take awhile to download.)

Share this post:

  • Tweet
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • More
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Apple Music website

Apple Faces the Music – Multiple Investigations Launched

Just days after Apple, Inc. announced its plans to attempt to reassert its leading role in the music distribution and streaming businesses, we learn from the New York Times that two powerful state attorneys general in New York and Connecticut have launched an investigation into Apple's music licensing practices. The…

June 11, 2015

In "Brands"

‘Legendary’ Judge Alsup Featured in Strata-gee May Go ‘Inactive’ in 2025

Featured in Sonos v. Google Patent Dispute Law360, a legal newsletter, reported on Tuesday that U.S. District Judge William H. Alsup - a judge in the Northern District of California - has filed papers with the court notifying it that he will likely take "inactive status" sometime in 2025. Calling…

May 29, 2025

In "Feature"

Split Decision: A Masimo Win and an Apple Win in High Stakes Legal War

An annotated copy of an illustration from a 2005 patent for a smartwatch (Kotanagi) containing the same or substantially similar technology that Apple was granted a patent for in 2021 While many things have changed in the wake of Joe Kiani's exit from Masimo Corporation (Nasdaq: MASI) - and many…

October 9, 2024

In "Feature"

Filed Under: Manufacturers, News, Strategy Tagged With: Apple, Dept. of Justice, Hachette, HarperCollins, iBookstore, Jobs, Macmillan, Penguin, Simon & Schuster, Steve

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Search

Sign-Up for Our FREE Newsletter

loader

Latest Posts

T-Day+1: Tariffs…And So It Begins…

**UPDATED 5/22/25** - See a Selection of Tariff Increases from Around the … [Read More...] about T-Day+1: Tariffs…And So It Begins…

In Its Boldest Move Yet, AVPro Global Acquires Control Solutions Maker RTI

We got a blockbuster announcement late this afternoon as AVPro Global announced … [Read More...] about In Its Boldest Move Yet, AVPro Global Acquires Control Solutions Maker RTI

  • T-Day+1: Tariffs…And So It Begins…
  • ‘Legendary’ Judge Alsup Featured in Strata-gee May Go ‘Inactive’ in 2025
  • Masimo Updates SEC on Its Progress Recovering From Recent Cyberattack
  • Harman Hits Voxx Int’l & Klipsch Group with Major 13-Count Lawsuit

Categories

Sponsors

Crestron Infra-Bass
AudioControl Single Zone Amps
Sonance James Small Aperture
Savant
Oasys Residential Technology Group

Tag Cloud

acquisition Amazon Apple AudioControl B&W Bowers & Wilkins CEDIA CEDIA Expo CES Control4 Core Brands COVID-19 Crestron D&M Holdings Denon Emerald Expositions Foxconn Gibson Brands Gibson Guitar Google Henry Juszkiewicz Hon Hai Precision Industry Co. housing starts Integra Joe Kiani LG Marantz Masimo Nortek OLED Onkyo Panasonic patent infringement Pioneer Samsung Savant Sharp smart home SnapAV Snap One Sonos Sony Sound United SpeakerCraft Toshiba

Footer

Got News?

HEY PR & Marketing Pros: Have NEWS for Strata-gee readers?

Send it to: HotNews@strata-gee.com

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Sponsor Strata-gee

Strata-gee Ads

Archives

Translate

Ted Green Bio

A former dealer, manufacturer, distributor & more. Focusing on business strategy, my goal is to help you make better decisions for greater success.

Follow Ted Green

  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram

Copyright © 2025 Strata-gee.com · The Stratecon Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved · Log in

%d